Showing posts with label US. Show all posts
Showing posts with label US. Show all posts

Sunday, November 17, 2013

US Government shut-down: what, why, who

Dan Roberts
theguardian.com, Monday 30 September 2013

What's going on?

Congress is fighting over how to authorise funding for the federal government beyond September. This used to be a fairly routine stage in the budget process, but has been hijacked by House Republicans, who are using the opportunity to make one last attempt to block Obamacare, the president's initiative to extend health insurance to those without cover.

Democrats in the Senate are refusing to pass any so-called "continuing resolution" if it weakens Obamacare, making a government shutdown increasingly likely.

What's really going on?

A battle for the soul of the Republican party is waging between conservatives with presidential ambitions or long-term ideological goals, and more moderate lawmakers who are worried about losing control of the House in the 2014 midterms.

Speaker John Boehner was initially reluctant to link Obamacare to the continuing resolution because he feared the inevitable shutdown would be blamed on Republicans and hurt their electoral chances much as it did to his predecessor Newt Gringrich after the last shutdown in the 1990s. However, an influential group of Tea Party radicals in the House has teamed up with senator Ted Cruz to force Boehner into a more confrontational strategy.

Who's to blame for this?

Boehner's weakness as leader of the House caucus is a big part of the problem. He struck a last-minute deal with vice-president Joe Biden to avert the last budget standoff, dubbed the fiscal cliff, in January, but this angered many on the right of his party, exacerbating rather than defusing the simmering tension.

He has little support from majority leader Eric Cantor, who is thought to be angling for his job, and Republican whip Kevin McCarthy, who is close to the Tea Party. Nevertheless, the majority of House Republicans were not previously thought to be so rabidly anti-government, and Boehner has failed to use their numerical advantage to further his more cautious instincts.

Other party heavyweights such as Cruz, Paul Ryan, Marco Rubio and Rand Paul are willing to let the Tea Party prevail because they need the right wing on their side to win a 2016 presidential primary. Senate majority leader Harry Reid is not without some blame either: urging President Obama against any talks at all with Republicans, who the Democrats compare to "terrorists".

Why now?

Congress has been at loggerheads over the federal budget ever since Democrats lost control of the House in 2010. As well as the fiscal cliff drama that played out over New Year, both parties narrowly averted a government shutdown in 2011 by striking a last-minute deal to cut spending.

This time, however, their differences may be harder to resolve because so much bad blood has already been spilled. Politically, Obama has little to lose from severing communications with congressional Republicans, because they are already blocking the two other things that matter to him – gun control and immigration – and is therefore even more reluctant to give up his only other big domestic achievement by delaying Obamacare.

But this lame duck status only encourages presidential hopefuls in both parties to focus more on jostling for longer-term advantage. The coincidence of this lapse in existing spending authorisation with the start of Obamacare's insurance exchanges and the forthcoming breach of government debt limits in two weeks may have led to a perfect storm.

Does it matter?

Government shutdowns have been survived before. In the 1970s they were commonplace – at least, until a legal ruling that forced non-essential workers to stay at home rather than work for IOUs. The second of Bill Clinton's standoffs with Newt Gringrich lasted 21 days over New Year 1995-6.

This time, however, the US economy is in much weaker shape, with a fragile recovery seen as vulnerable to the dip in consumer confidence that a protracted shutdown would probably bring. More worryingly, the debt ceiling breach expected on October 17 presents an incentive for diehards on both sides to keep fighting their corner as long as possible.

If a shutdown is not resolved within a week or so, the two issues are likely to be conflated into one giant standoff that threatens not just federal workers but the world economy.

How will it end?

A slightly more optimistic scenario is that Boehner succeeds in using the upcoming debt fight as a way to persuade his hardliners to let the continuing resolution pass and postpone their Obamacare fight until next month. This would only buy time, but would at least bring the shutdown to a swift conclusion.

The chances of more lasting resolution, or "grand bargain", as it optimistically became known during the fiscal cliff drama, look close to zero, with the sides where they are at present. The best hope for many Democrats is that Republicans receive so much public opprobrium that they lose the 2014 midterms or change tack to avoid that happening.


Conservative Republicans would be happy to see Obama forced to cede as much power as possible over domestic policy and are likely to carry on focusing on their core supporters, perhaps until after the 2016 primaries. And Speaker Boehner may be happy if he can strike a deal that lets him hang on to his job for another few weeks.

Saturday, November 16, 2013

'Obamacare'

One of the central provisions of President Barack Obama and the Democrats' healthcare reform law, known popularly as "Obamacare", took effect on 1 October 2014. But the rollout has been a White House public relations nightmare, with a federal website bedevilled by errors and millions of Americans' existing policies cancelled, contrary to Mr Obama's promise.

The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, signed by Mr Obama in 2010, is the largest overhaul of the US healthcare system since the 1960s.

What does the law do?

Its aim is simple: to extend health insurance coverage to some of the estimated 15% of the US population who lack it. Those people receive no coverage from their employers and are not covered by US health programmes for the poor and the elderly. To achieve this, the law requires all Americans to have health insurance, but offers subsidies to make coverage more affordable and aims to reduce the cost of insurance by bringing younger, healthier people into the health insurance system. It also requires businesses with more than 50 full-time employees to offer health coverage, although this provision was delayed until 2015 to allow more time for compliance.

The law creates marketplaces - with websites akin to online travel and shopping sites - where individuals can compare prices as they shop for coverage. In addition, the law bans insurance companies from denying health coverage to people with pre-existing health conditions, allows young people to remain on their parents' plans until age 26, and expands eligibility for the government-run Medicaid health programme for the poor. The law aims eventually to slow the growth of US healthcare spending, which is the highest in the world.

What happened to the website?

Healthcare.gov is a federal website that serves as a marketplace where individuals in 36 states can compare private insurance plans, learn about available public subsidies, and sign up for a coverage. The remaining 14 states and Washington DC have set up their own websites. The federal portal was plagued with technical glitches from its roll-out on 1 October, including long sign-in wait times, log-in difficulties, insurance account creation problems, slow page loads and outages. Exchanges run by individual states did not appear to have the same problems. Enrolment figures for the first month were a fifth of what the Obama administration initially projected.The White House has promised a "smooth experience" for the "vast majority" of website users by the end of November.

Why were some Americans' plans cancelled?

In autumn 2013, insurance companies began announcing the cancellation of millions of policies that do not meet the law's minimum requirements, including coverage of a range of preventive and emergency healthcare. Millions of Americans with individual plans were affected, despite Mr Obama's oft-repeated promise that those who liked their plans "could keep them". Mr Obama apologised to those whose policies had been cancelled and then announced he would be giving a one-year reprieve from the cancellations. But insurance firms have questioned whether the proposed fix is workable.

Why do conservatives oppose the law?

Republicans say the law imposes too many costs on business, with many describing it as a "job killer". They have also decried it as an unwarranted intrusion into the affairs of private businesses and individuals. The party and a veritable industry of conservative think tanks and advocacy groups have fought the law since Mr Obama first proposed it in 2009 at the start of his first term in office. After the law was passed in 2010, Republicans launched a legal challenge, which ended in June 2012 when the US Supreme Court declared it constitutional. It was also a central issue in the 2012 presidential election, when Mr Obama won a second term in office.Meanwhile, the House of Representatives, controlled by the Republicans, has taken dozens of symbolic votes to repeal the law and forced a partial government shutdown over the issue. Republicans in state capitals have also sought to undermine it in various ways.Democrats say Republicans are politically motivated to attack Mr Obama's flagship domestic achievement in order to weaken him.

When do its elements take effect?

The law takes effect in several stages:

2010: Insurers were banned from denying coverage to children with pre-existing conditions, adults under 26 years of age were allowed to remain on their parents' plans, and insurers were barred from cancelling coverage in some circumstances. Insurers were forbidden from imposing lifetime limits on health coverage.

2011: The law expanded access to preventative health services, and offered drug discounts for people in the Medicare programme for pensioners.

2012: Provisions to encourage healthcare providers to lower costs took effect.
October 2013: Consumer health insurance marketplaces go online, and is plagued by snags and glitches.


2014: People without health coverage from the government or their employers will be required to purchase it. The government Medicaid health programme for the poor will be expanded to cover more people, tax credits will subsidise individual and family purchases of health policies, and insurers will be barred from denying coverage to those with pre-existing health conditions.

15 November 2013 Last updated at 01:55 GMT